
by Raymond Chandler
Rating: ★★★★
Series: Philip Marlowe #3
Publication Date: August 17, 1942
Genre: noir
Pages: 272
ReRead?: Yes
Project: 2025 read my hoard, a century of crime, summer of noir
Fast-talking, trouble-seeking private eye Philip Marlowe is a different kind of detective: a moral man in an amoral world. California in the ’40s and ’50s is as beautiful as a ripe fruit and rotten to the core, and Marlowe must struggle to retain his integrity amidst the corruption he encounters daily.
In The High Window, Marlowe starts out on the trail of a single stolen coin and ends up knee-deep in bodies. His client, a dried-up husk of a woman, wants him to recover a rare gold coin called a Brasher Doubloon, missing from her late husband’s collection. That’s the simple part.
But Marlowe finds that everyone who handles the coin suffers a run of very bad luck: they always end up dead. If Marlowe doesn’t wrap this one up fast, he’s going to end up in jail - or worse, in a box in the ground.
Starring Toby Stephens, this thrilling dramatisation by Robin Brooks retains all the wry humour of Chandler’s serpentine suspense novel. It was first broadcast on BBC Radio 4 on 8 October 2011.
It felt like this is the point at which Chandler settled comfortably into his character and his style. He has a knack for scene setting, which shows in the opening paragraph
The house was on Dresden Avenue in the Oak Noll section of Pasadena, a big sold cool-looking house with burgundy brick walls, a terra cotta tile roof, and a white stone trim. The front windows were leaded downstairs and had a lot of rococo imitation stonework trimming around them.
From the front wall and its attendant flower bushes, a half acre of so of fine green lawn drifted in a gentl slope down to the street, passing on the way an enormous deodar around which it flowed like a cool green tide around a rock.
Marlowe has been called to the home of a wealthy widow to recover a valuable, and rare, coin: the Brasher doubloon. He is told by Mrs. Murdock, the widow, that it was stolen by her daughter-in-law, who absconded with the coin and her son’s heart. This is a very basic set up for what turns out to be a very complicated scheme that – as usual – ends in a series of sordid murders. He is told, severely, that he is not allowed to talk to anyone about the job, including the son. Mrs. Murdock has a young secretary, Merle, who will figure prominently in the story.
The son shows up at Marlowe’s office shortly after he leaves the house in Pasadena.
He didn’t curl his lip because it had been curled when he came in. “A private detective,” he said. “I never met one. A shifty business, one gathers. Keyhole peeping, raking up scandal, that sort of thing.”
“You here on business,” I asked him, “or just slumming?”
His smile was as faint at a fat lady at a fireman’s ball.
Chandler has a unique way with words, which excuses the fact that his plots are convoluted and thin. The High Window, like the prior two novels, is full of gold nugget language to excavate.
But, as well, Marlowe himself has become wholly convincing as a sort of a hero. Not an anti-hero, which has become ubiquitously, and sort of sadly in my opinion, popular in this nihlist age in which we live, but the real thing. Bashed about, a bit dented, but a real hero.
In this, he makes me think of Harry Bosch (or, more accurately, Harry Bosch makes me think of him) to the point that I wonder if Michael Connelly had Chandler’s LA and Marlowe himself in mind when he began writing his long-running series, which I have been reading for more than three decades. Bosch – who represents the uncorruptible side of law enforcement – has a credo – Everybody counts or nobody counts.
In Chandler’s LA, you count only if you count. If you are important or rich, or famous in some way. Marlowe swims in a sea of corruption, but maintains an integrity and a sense of honor that everyone around him seems to entirely lack. The government is corrupt. The police are corrupt. Everyone is beholden and bought and paid for by someone else. In talking to a police officer, he says:
Until you guys own your own souls you don’t own mine. Until you guys can be trusted everytime and always, in all times and conditions, to seek the truth out and find it and let the chips fall where they may – until that time comes, I have the right to listen to my conscience…
This is the conflict that has animated the Bosch series from the beginning, because Harry Bosch is a cop who can be trusted everytime and always, in all times and conditions, to seek the truth out and find it and let the chips fall where they may. And he has spent 20+ books at odds with the LAPD brass, which is less than worthy of this trust. From 1942 to 2025, the more things change, the more they stay the same.
“Phil Marlowe,” he said, “The shop-soiled Galahad.”
This was the last novel in my collection of “the early novels,” which also contained a bunch of the pulp stories. I am not a huge short story fan, so I may or may not circle back to read them at some point. Next up, though, is The Lady in the Lake, but first I’m going to branch out and read The Killer Inside Me by Jim Thompson.